| Platinum | Babcock Auto Care |
| Gold | Valvoline Instant Oil Change |
| Silver | Broadway Car Care |
| Bronze | The Auto Garage |
| Top Pick | Bird's Auto |
| Top Pick | Kilians Express Lube |
| Top Pick | Kilians Express Lube LLC |
| Top Pick | Rochester Ford Sales & Service |
| Top Pick | Rochester Motor Cars |
| Top Pick | Virgil's Auto Repair and Towing |