| Platinum | Victoria's Restaurant and Wine Bar |
| Gold | Five West Kitchen + Bar |
| Silver | Crave |
| Bronze | Hubbell House |
| Top Pick | Bleu Duck Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Latitude 44 |
| Top Pick | Marrow |
| Top Pick | Olde Brick House |
| Top Pick | Our Paladar |
| Top Pick | Pittsburgh Blue Steakhouse |