| Platinum | Refashion Consigned Furniture & Clothing |
| Gold | Old River Valley Antique Mall |
| Silver | Clothes Mentor |
| Silver | Kismet Consignment Fashion & Home Decor |
| Bronze | Goodwill Stores |
| Top Pick | Children's Exchange & Maternity Exchange |
| Top Pick | Janky Gear |
| Top Pick | Ragstock |
| Top Pick | Rochester Restore |
| Top Pick | Yellow Monkey |