| Platinum | Nothing Bundt Cakes |
| Gold | Some Like It Hot and Gluten Free |
| Silver | Sam's Club |
| Bronze | Otto's Bakery & Coffee Shop |
| Top Pick | Alisha's Sweet Treats |
| Top Pick | Cakes Etcetera |
| Top Pick | Creatively Katz' Gluten Free Treats |
| Top Pick | Hy-Vee |
| Top Pick | Hy-Vee Barlows |
| Top Pick | Seto Bakery |