| Platinum | Discount Tire |
| Gold | Prestige Auto & Diesel |
| Silver | Heartland Tire Service |
| Bronze | Bauer Built Tire & Service |
| Top Pick | Automotive Procare |
| Top Pick | Costco |
| Top Pick | Happy Hyundai of Rochester |
| Top Pick | Joe's Auto & Tire |
| Top Pick | Midas |
| Top Pick | Tilson's Auto Repair |