| Platinum | Alisha's Sweet Treats |
| Gold | Great Harvest Bread Company |
| Silver | Crumbl Cookies - Rochester |
| Bronze | People's Food Co-op |
| Top Pick | Baked by Kara |
| Top Pick | Desserts by Danna |
| Top Pick | Five West Kitchen + Bar |
| Top Pick | Great American Cookies |
| Top Pick | North Mr Pizza |
| Top Pick | Some Like It Hot and Gluten Free |
| Top Pick | Tinn's Grilled Philly Steak Subs |