| Platinum | Sorellina's |
| Gold | Victoria's Restaurant and Wine Bar |
| Silver | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Terza Restaurant |
| Bronze | Pasquale's Neighborhood Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Carbone's Pizza and Sports Bar |
| Top Pick | Herb+Arrow Bar Kitchen |
| Top Pick | North Mr Pizza |
| Top Pick | Nupa Mediterranean Cuisine |
| Top Pick | The Lost Dutchman |