| Platinum | Pasquale's Neighborhood Pizzeria |
| Platinum | The Original Mr. Pizza South |
| Gold | Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza |
| Silver | Red's Savoy Pizza |
| Bronze | O'Neill Pizza Pub |
| Top Pick | BB's Pizzzaria |
| Top Pick | Broadway Bar & Pizza |
| Top Pick | North Mr Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rosati's Pizza |
| Top Pick | The Lost Dutchman |