| Platinum | Kismet Consignment Fashion & Home Decor |
| Gold | Real Deals on Home Decor |
| Silver | Flowers By Jerry |
| Bronze | 5th Grant Boutique |
| Top Pick | Ama La Vita |
| Top Pick | Chappie's "Consignment for Dudes" |
| Top Pick | Clover and Rose |
| Top Pick | Refashion Consigned Furniture & Clothing |